
Ally & Eloise
Columbia bakery with two storefronts on Devine Street and Forest Drive, voted Best Wedding Cake Baker in Columbia three years running and Best Bakery in 2025.
Cakes · Columbia & Midlands
A family-run cake studio operating from a St. Matthews farm, serving Columbia and the Midlands with buttercream wedding cakes from about $6 a serving.





At a Glance
Services
About
Bonnie Brunt runs this cake studio from her family's farm in St. Matthews, about 40 miles southeast of Columbia, with a team of five decorators including a Studio Art graduate who leads sugar flower work and a Johnson & Wales-trained pastry cook. Brunt first sold cakes out of her home in the late 1980s, stopped for about a decade, and rebuilt the business starting in 2010; it has since grown into a full-time wedding cake studio serving the Midlands and beyond.
Buttercream wedding cakes start around $6 per serving, with the shop's average custom order closer to $6.50; two flavors are included per tiered cake, with a $35 charge for each additional flavor and extra fees for premium options. Recipes include Mississippi sweet potato, fresh strawberry, and red velvet cakes finished in buttercream, cream cheese, or hand-piped sugar flowers, and the team coordinates directly with a couple's florist to place fresh flowers on the cake. A limited gluten-free cake is available, though the kitchen is not celiac-safe.
Cake consultations run $55 to $60 for an in-person tasting of up to four guests, or a free virtual tasting by video call; a $250 non-refundable deposit reserves a wedding date, which the shop recommends booking six to twelve months ahead. Delivery and setup across the Midlands costs a standard $135, with additional fees for longer trips; the shop has delivered cakes as far as Charlotte and Charleston. Pickup hours run Monday through Thursday at 440 Great Circle Dr. in St. Matthews.
Location
440 Great Circle Dr., St. Matthews, SC 29135
Keep Comparing

Columbia bakery with two storefronts on Devine Street and Forest Drive, voted Best Wedding Cake Baker in Columbia three years running and Best Bakery in 2025.

A Lexington chocolate and candy shop on Ellis Avenue that also bakes made-to-order wedding cakes, with three-tier cakes starting at a published $259.

A Five Points, Columbia bakery opened in 2021 by a longtime home baker, offering per-serving wedding cakes, monthly tastings, and two vegan cupcake flavors.